42nd & Boulevard · Butler-Tarkington
Help restore Tarkington House.
We’d like to restore the house at 42nd Street and Boulevard Place and open it as a neighborhood coffeehouse and ice cream shop.
Sign a letter of supportRead the letter, enter your details, and type your name as your signature. Then select Submit.

A place for the neighborhood
Coffee, conversation,
and a familiar corner.
Stop in for coffee, bring the kids for ice cream, or settle in with a book in a cozy nook inspired by Booth Tarkington.
The landscaped wraparound patio would have room to sit and catch up, with space indoors and out for neighborhood events. We’re also proposing a mural facing the intersection that tells a story from Butler-Tarkington’s history, bike-share spaces tucked into the landscaping, and better signs and lighting to make the corner easier to navigate after dark.
Read the letter of support
Metropolitan Board of Zoning Appeals, Division II
Indianapolis-Marion County, Indiana
Re: 4201 Boulevard Place | Case 2026-UV2-014
Dear Members of the Board:
I support the requested use variance for Tarkington House, a proposed neighborhood coffee shop at 4201 Boulevard Place in Butler-Tarkington. I respectfully ask the Board to approve the request.
Tarkington House could strengthen the Butler-Tarkington community by giving neighbors a regular place to meet and build relationships. A local coffeehouse, creamery, and bookshop would bring longtime residents, newer neighbors, and families together. I would welcome a place where people recognize familiar faces, meet someone who lives a few blocks away, and build a stronger sense of community.
I also support the owners' plan to restore the historic grandeur of the home. Caring for this familiar property and giving it a community use would help preserve the character of the corner. The proposed indoor seating, wraparound patio, and landscaped gathering areas would create more opportunities for neighbors to connect.
The planned mural, inspired by Butler-Tarkington's streetcar history and literary heritage, would celebrate the neighborhood's identity and help share its stories with children, new neighbors, and visitors.
I believe any impact on traffic or parking would be outweighed by the benefits of restoring this property and creating a welcoming place for neighbors to gather, build relationships, and strengthen the community.
For these reasons, I believe Tarkington House would benefit Butler-Tarkington. Thank you for considering my support.
Complete your details and signature in the online letter form, or download an editable copy.
Questions about the project or signing a letter? Email Julie.
Proposed project, subject to zoning approval · Case 2026-UV2-014